This was an interesting listen for me and I liked how the husband (policeman) was, like in many of these episodes, quick to call someone a witch and did some research on it.  I also liked the bird and cat as being aspects of the old woman (which [not witch] I just saw duplicated as my kids were watching Spy Kids 3 [Sylvester Stalone's character had 3 aspects of himself]).  The sound effects were pretty good and another pretty good Ian Martin story.

Melanie - To be honest I'd have to look at the titles to make a determination of which are my favorites.  There are definitely more on certain writers that I like more, certain actors that I like more, some adaptations I like more, and some themes that I like more.  This is actually my second time listening through and it's interesting on which ones I remember and which ones I don't.  For some reason I ALWAYS remember the very first one - The Old Ones are Hard to Kill (I think I got that right).  There are a few others that I remember the stories, but not necessarily the titles.  I don't think I heard too many of them when I was growing up listening to them on WCCO in the Twin Cities of Minnesota, but there was only 1 that I really remembered and I heard it again the first time I went through all of them.  However, for the life of me I don't remember the title and I remembered it differently than it actually was (although I may have been interrupted when listening when I was younger or fell asleep).