In regards to "You're Going to Like Rodney", I had never heard of this one, before it was posted here, but thought it was an excellent story. It's one of those stories that, for me, works best with no visuals, relying on good story telling to visualize scenes; had this been a video it may not have been as effective. I thought the near drowning in the pool, early in the story was creepy, along with going up the stairs to see the butterfly collection. This is one of those stories that I will listen to again and recommend to others.

The top 5 lists are fun to read and I rely on them for what I queue up in my iPod to listen to, so I thank the other memebers for posting their favorites. It's also fun to compare notes. Like another member said, there's more goes into a list of favorites than just being good stories. A large part of it is "what does this story remind me of? What fond memory surfaces?"

Anyway, here's my current favorites:

1. The Ninth Volume

2. The Magic Stick of Manitu

3. The Black Room

4. Time and Again

5. Murder to Perfection

Like others, the list is subject to change as I listen to more shows.