Definitely one of the best. Think I know every line of this one now. Have probably played it while falling asleep 150 times in the past few years. Amy Hastings, Ralph Cook, George Smith, Fred Russell, Lois Wilson: the names try a bit too hard to seem 'typical', but they only add to the coolness after a while.

Favorite lines are when Lois Wilson tries to fire an arrow and misses wildly, almost hitting Amy Hastings, and then remarks:
"I think I'd have been better off without...help"
And, George Smith senses the accusation and replies: "What are you trying to say, Lois?"
"Nothing, I'm just glad that Amy's alright"

Cracks me up every time.

"Let's dance, it'll seem more natural"...Suave, damn, Ralph Cook is one suave f__k!

There is like a short list of 10-15 CBS Radio Mystery Theatre episodes that really stand above the others. IMHO, this is one of them.