Come on. I think you're overstating it. After all, for all his good scripts, Sam Dann wrote his fair share of bloody awful stinkers through the years too, and no mistake. He'd probably admit it himself. No artist is perfect. It's the nature of the creative process---especially when you're stuggling to crank out as many scripts as you can to make a living in the Big Apple and put food on the table.

Each writer for the show specialized in a certain type of story. I imagine Himan Brown planned it that way for variety's sake--to appeal to the tastes of as many different listeners as possible. It's probably why the show lasted as long as it did. But they're all good writers. They were well-chosen, and very skilled in each of their particular areas, if not always perfect.